If the UK’s EDI community is after a cautionary tale from the first six months of Trump 2.0, it doesn’t need to look too far to find it.

What began as a movement to address historical inequities in the workplace and society has, in the United States, become a battleground.

EDI programmes in universities, corporations, and public institutions have come under fierce attack from political and cultural forces that view them as ideological overreach. In some states, legislative efforts have sought to limit or defund diversity initiatives entirely.

In this climate, EDI has been reframed from a moral and strategic imperative to a source of division. The UK is not there – yet – but we would be wise to recognise the signs and take steps to protect the principles and progress of inclusion before any similar backlash gains traction here.

A new white paper from Convergent, Freedom of Expression and Belief are the new EDI Frontier, outlines the early symptoms of such tension in the UK.

Drawing on employer insights, tribunal trends, and practical case studies, the paper makes clear that belief-related disputes are not just an American phenomenon – they are already emerging in British workplaces.

From gender-critical beliefs to religious objections and political expression, a growing number of employees are challenging the limits of what inclusion really means – and for whom. What is emerging is a deeply complex picture, in which the pursuit of inclusion for one group can be perceived as exclusion or suppression by another.

This is rightly unsettling for EDI practitioners in the UK, who have tended to see their work as benevolent, and even self-evidently good.

But Convergent’s research shows this assumption no longer holds. Increasingly, some staff view EDI training and policy as coercive, biased, or at odds with their own identity or beliefs.

And whilst these perceptions may not reflect the intention of EDI programmes – perception, especially when tied to employment law, matters.

The challenge is doubled down in the shape of widespread lack of confidence among EDI professionals themselves. In the report, practitioners confess uncertainty about how to handle belief-based pushback. They worry about causing offence, being drawn into grievance processes, or appearing partisan.

The hesitancy is understandable, yet hardly new, especially given the rise in steady high-profile legal cases involving conflicting rights. But it also leaves EDI efforts vulnerable.

If inclusion work is to retain its legitimacy and effectiveness, it cannot retreat from difficult conversations. Nor can it rely on outdated models that assume everyone shares the same view of progress.

One lesson from the American experience is that a failure to engage with criticism – however uncomfortable – creates space for backlash to flourish. To learn more about this take a look at our Feb 2025 white paper: The Unity Playbook which directly address the US EDI backlash.

In the US, a lack of nuance in the broad EDI conversation has allowed its opponents to paint the field as ideologically rigid and inherently dismissive of dissent. In some cases, this portrayal has been exaggerated or unfair. But in others, it has resonated with people who felt alienated or silenced.

The UK must resist the temptation to ignore this dynamic. Instead, we should take a proactive approach, grounded in legal literacy, open dialogue, and a deeper understanding of competing beliefs.

Convergent’s white paper suggests several avenues for doing just that. It calls for a shift away from one-size-fits-all inclusion narratives and a move towards a more pluralistic, legally informed framework that recognises the diversity of thought as much as identity.

That means giving EDI teams the tools to navigate competing rights without defaulting to avoidance or defensiveness.

It also means embedding a clearer understanding of the Equality Act 2010 across organisations – particularly the legal protections it affords to religion and belief. Too often, the law is misquoted or misunderstood, leaving employers exposed to claims that could have been prevented with better education.

Perhaps most importantly, the paper challenges EDI professionals to reflect critically on their own practices.

Are policies and training sessions presented as invitations to think, or as mandates to agree? Are belief-related conflicts dismissed as bad-faith challenges, or seen as opportunities to clarify, adapt and grow?

If inclusion is to mean anything at all, we must surely make a point of ensuring it extends to those with whom we disagree.

That doesn’t mean tolerating hate or discrimination – far from it – but it does require the confidence to hold boundaries with clarity and consistency, not fear.

The UK has a real opportunity to chart a different course. Our legal framework provides a strong basis for balancing competing rights, and our cultural context allows for more pragmatism than polarisation.

But this opportunity will only be realised if EDI practitioners are willing to evolve. That means rejecting imported polarities, avoiding echo chambers, and equipping ourselves with the legal, ethical, and interpersonal tools to engage constructively with conflict.

It also means building alliances beyond the EDI silo – with legal teams, line managers, HR leaders, and even sceptical voices who may challenge assumptions but who remain open to dialogue and constructive debate.

The stakes are high. If the UK follows the US path, the consequences will be severe – not just for EDI professionals, but for the staff and organisations they serve.

Reputational damage, costly litigation, and the erosion of trust all follow when inclusion efforts are perceived as one-sided or disconnected from reality. But with courage, clarity and humility, the EDI community can avoid this fate.

Convergent’s message is ultimately one of hope. Conflict is not a sign of failure. It is a signal that the conversation matters. The task now is to lead that conversation with intelligence, integrity and a commitment to inclusion that holds space for difference – not division.