You cannot participate in the creation of a new world and doubt it at the same time.

I must have a great algorithm on X, because whilst so many people are railing against it, I’m regularly seeing things that get me thinking. This phrase struck a chord with me and triggered a surprising moment of reflection about the work I do.

I am ferociously passionate about equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI). There is not a single fibre within me that doesn’t wholeheartedly and fundamentally believe in the overriding principle that we are all entitled to be treated equally and fairly at work. We all need to earn a living and that need should be met without tolerating being treated badly by those we work with.

There is already enough in the world that we can’t control that diminishes and divides us – geography, climate, politics, and conflict, among others – without us contributing further to it through behaviour we can control.

For all those reasons and many more, I know that the work I and others operating in this space do every day is essential in creating a new world where the injustices of inequality and exclusion are absent.

And yet. And yet.

I am also sometimes overcome by a sense of futility that blurs into a dark smudge of pointlessness at the scale of the work that needs to be done, the mindsets that would benefit from being questioned, and the behaviours too.

At its very essence, my work is designed to make me redundant – in this new world I am helping to build, I will not be needed. And that’s really at the heart of the doubt that sometimes sneaks up on me and sits at my shoulder.

Is that world even possible?

For many of us, working in EDI is a labour of love, a field where passion meets purpose, with practitioners striving to dismantle barriers, interrupt biases, challenge systemic inequalities, and create spaces where everyone can thrive.

Yet, I don’t think I’m alone in feeling this unspoken reality of tension between hope and doubt.

So, what happens when those of us working to create a new world question whether our efforts are truly effective? How do we navigate the weight of cynicism while staying committed to the cause?

I think I’ve concluded that this tension is not only inevitable but also deeply human. It reflects the complexities of tackling profound societal issues. Let’s explore the challenges of this duality and how we can find meaning and resilience in the process.

The weight of resistance

One of the most significant challenges in EDI work is the resistance to change.

As a result, advocates like myself often find themselves facing opposition, whether it’s overt pushback or subtle inertia.

These barriers can make progress feel slow and disheartening, nourishing doubts about whether meaningful change is achievable within the constraints of existing systems that are routinely prevalent even in a time when awareness of EDI is that much greater.

Resistance isn’t limited to external forces; it can also manifest internally. I know the principles that I’m working to implement are desirable, but I’m no less immune to inner conflict than anyone else.

Who am I, I sometimes wonder, to confront such monumental challenges alone? I’m not the only one to feel this, I’m sure, and it is this internal resistance that compounds the external struggles, creating a feedback loop of doubt.

The tokenism trap

Another significant hurdle is the prevalence of performative EDI effort. Many organisations adopt the language of diversity and inclusion but fail to implement meaningful, structural change.

Initiatives can sometimes feel like box-ticking exercises—hiring diverse candidates without fostering inclusive environments, celebrating cultural holidays without addressing harassment of the groups being celebrated, or rolling out training programmes that fail to move beyond awareness.

For practitioners, having the sense that your work is being reduced to optics or compliance is demoralising and it becomes easy to question whether we’re genuinely building a better world, or simply enabling institutions to maintain the status quo under the guise of progress?

But I think that perhaps this scepticism is valid and necessary, because while the clash between genuine intentions and performative realities creates a mental and emotional burden, it also pushes me to ask hard questions about the authenticity of my efforts and the true beneficiaries of my work.

The emotional toll of advocacy

I’ve realised that my work is inherently emotional. It demands that I confront difficult truths about who has influence and who experiences inequality in any given situation, whilst trying at the same time to foster hope and empathy in the people experiencing those truths.

For those who should benefit most from what I do, the EDI efforts of their organisations can feel intrusive, patronising and exhausting, as it often involves reliving trauma, navigating microaggressions, or battling an internalised sense of oppression that may have come from a well-meaning place, but it isn’t helping them.

Even for advocates outside these communities, the emotional strain is significant. Watching progress stall or regress – whether through political setbacks, organisational resistance, or societal backlash – can lead to burnout and cynicism.

The emotional toll is compounded by a feeling of isolation. Advocates may find themselves in the minority, particularly in spaces where diversity is not yet a priority. The weight of being the ‘voice of change’ in resistant environments can be exhausting, fostering doubts about whether the fight is worth it.

Impact fatigue – the frustration of slow progress

In an ideal world, the impact of EDI would be immediate and transformative. In the real world, change unfolds incrementally, and progress is rarely linear. It can take months and sometimes years of work to implement initiatives, only to see modest results or even regression.

If change is so gradual, I sometimes find myself wondering, is it even worth it? Will I see the fruits of my labour within my working life, or even within my lifetime?

Unsurprisingly, these questions are especially prominent in moments of crisis or backlash, when progress seems to backslide, and hard-earned gains are called into question.

Impact fatigue is real, and it can erode the motivation of even the most committed advocate. When the outcomes of your work feel distant or intangible, it’s easy to fall into the trap of cynicism.

Balancing idealism and realism

At its core, EDI work is about imagining and striving for a better world. This requires a degree of idealism – a belief in the possibility of transformation. Yet, idealism can clash with the pragmatic realities of the systems we operate within.

Idealism is necessary to inspire change, but unchecked, it can lead to disappointment when reality falls short, and then people start preaching – (the sign of a failed methodology, I might add). Realism, on the other hand, helps ground strategies in practicality, but risks devolving into defeatism.

The challenge lies in holding both perspectives simultaneously: believing in the vision of a new world while acknowledging the limitations of the current one.

Finding resilience in the face of doubt

Despite these challenges, it is possible to navigate the tension between hope and cynicism. There are strategies for maintaining resilience and purpose in EDI work, and perspective is everything.

It’s why, when I find myself doubting my role in the creation of this new world, I try to see my work in the moment.

I celebrate small wins – each step forward – whether it’s changing one policy, influencing one decision-maker, or shifting one perspective – contributes to the broader movement.

I try to build collective support – EDI should never be a solitary endeavour, but a shared experience with people who share my vision and provide validation, encouragement, and fresh perspectives when doubt creeps in. I’m human after all.

I reframe what success looks like – a single workshop or conversation might not change the world, but it can change minds—and that’s a powerful starting point.

I acknowledge this duality that occasionally torments me – understanding that doubt and hope can coexist. Cynicism doesn’t negate the value of my work, it simply reflects my critical engagement with its complexities.

Embracing the Paradox

EDI work asks us to believe in the possibility of a new world while confronting the immense challenges of building it. It requires both optimism and realism, persistence and patience, hope and doubt.

Cynicism, while uncomfortable, can serve as a check against complacency, a reminder to strive for deeper, more meaningful change.

In the end, the act of participating in EDI work – despite its challenges, imperfections, and uncertainties – is itself a radical act of hope in which I imagine a world that doesn’t yet exist, and then I work, however imperfectly, to bring it closer to reality.

So, to those who also find themselves grappling with doubt: take heart. Our efforts matter, even if their full impact is not immediately visible.

The work of creating a new world is not easy, but it is necessary—and that is what makes it worth it.