Eleven of B Lab’s 19 new JEDI actions would survive scrutiny in a UK tribunal. Five wouldn’t. Three depend on whether you built the mechanism or just set the target. Will B Lab’s new framing survive contact with the organisations that need to implement it? Read on for an action-by-action analysis of B Lab’s 19 JEDI requirements – what’s structural, what’s attitudinal/optical, and why the framing puts the substance at risk.

What B Lab Has Actually Done

Large companies are recertifying under B Lab’s new standards from January 2026. From 2027, every B Corp recertification – regardless of size – must meet the new framework. For approximately 2,700 certified UK companies, the deadline is no longer abstract. It is in the next recertification cycle.

The framework itself was published by B Lab in April 2025 – the most significant overhaul of B Corp certification in its 19-year history. The old points-based system, where companies could score 80 on the B Impact Assessment by excelling in some areas while performing poorly in others, has been replaced by mandatory requirements across seven impact topics. Companies can no longer offset weakness in one area with strength in another.

One of those seven mandatory topics is Justice, Equity, Diversity and Inclusion (JEDI). Every certified B Corp must now meet minimum JEDI standards to achieve recertification, which is required every three years.

The JEDI topic has two core requirements. First, companies must collect demographic and experience data from their workforce (JEDI1). Second, they must choose and implement a specified number of actions from a menu of 19 options (JEDI2), with the number and rigour scaling by company size. Companies must maintain a written JEDI plan with deadlines, resource allocation, and role assignments, updated annually.

So far, so structural. The question is whether the framing survives contact with the organisations that need to implement it.

 

The Structural vs Attitudinal/Optical Distinction

The evidence base for EDI interventions is not evenly distributed. Structural interventions – blind recruitment, structured interviews, standardised evaluation criteria, pay audits, process design, third-party verification – have a substantially stronger evidence base than attitudinal/optical interventions – commitment statements, awareness campaigns, language guides, employee resource groups.

In the UK this distinction matters legally as well as practically. Under the Equality Act 2010, the statutory defence available to employers (s.109(4)) requires evidence of steps taken to prevent discrimination or harassment. From October 2026, the Employment Rights Act 2025 raises the bar from “reasonable steps” to “all reasonable steps” for the preventative duty on harassment. Sexual harassment has been held to this standard since 2024 when the Worker Protection Act came into effect. The leading case on what fails this test – Allay (UK) Ltd v Gehlen (EAT, 2021) – rejected a defence built on stale, untailored training. The tribunal found the training was “clearly stale” because the harasser considered his racial comments to be “banter” and managers who witnessed it failed to act.

The question for any EDI framework is: does it require things that would survive that test? Things that create a documented evidence trail, measurable outcomes, and process change – not just good intentions and good optics?

I have assessed each of B Lab’s 19 JEDI actions against this distinction. The results are more interesting than you might expect.

 

The 19 JEDI Actions: Action-by-Action Analysis Foundation Actions (JEDI2.a-e)

These are the building blocks: leadership commitments, training, policy review, representation targets, and external audits.

Source link in table:

 

Within the Workplace (JEDI2.f-l)

These actions extend beyond the organisation to suppliers, customers, products, and advocacy.

Source link in table:

 

Beyond the Workplace (JEDI2.m-s)

These actions extend beyond the organisation to suppliers, customers, products, and advocacy.

The Scorecard

Of B Lab’s 19 JEDI actions, the majority are structural interventions with measurable outcomes and auditable evidence trails. That is a better ratio than most voluntary EDI frameworks. It is also a better ratio than most employers’ current EDI programmes.

The Problem: Right Substance, Wrong Packaging

If you stripped the JEDI branding from B Lab’s requirements and listed them as “operational compliance standards,” no CFO would blink. Policy audits. Third-party verification. Structured hiring. Accessibility compliance. Supplier diversity tracking. Pay gap analysis disaggregated by protected characteristic. These are process interventions. They are measurable, auditable, and defensible.

But B Lab did not strip the branding. They wrapped structural interventions in justice-and-belonging language at exactly the moment the corporate world is running from that language. The Observer’s 2025 analysis of FTSE 100 annual reports found mentions of EDI fell by more than 16% across 85 companies between 2023 and 2024.

B Lab’s response to this retreat was to double down. They named the pillar “Justice, Equity, Diversity and Inclusion.” They described it as a framework for “systems repair.” They included an action (JEDI2.s) that requires companies to “participate in collective initiatives to drive systems change” – language that positions JEDI not as a business standard but as a social movement.

This creates a specific, foreseeable risk. If companies start dropping B Corp certification because JEDI sounds like activism, the structural interventions go with it. The policy audits. The structured hiring. The accessibility compliance. The supplier diversity tracking. All of it – gone. Not because the substance was wrong, but because the packaging made it politically vulnerable.

The baby goes out with the bathwater.

Why This Matters Beyond B Corp

The B Corp JEDI framework is a case study in a problem that affects every organisation working on EDI. The interventions that work – the ones with an evidence base, the ones that survive legal scrutiny, the ones that produce measurable outcomes – are often buried inside frameworks that package them as values commitments rather than operational standards.

When the political weather changes, the values framing becomes a liability. Organisations that built their EDI on “because it’s the right thing to do” discover that this argument has no structural foundation. A different pressure arrives – a US executive order, a board that wants to distance from “EDI”, a CFO who sees the label as reputational risk – and the programme collapses. Because it was never built on process. It was built on optics and emotion.

The alternative is to build EDI on what actually works: structural process design, legal compliance, measurable outcomes, and documented evidence trails. Call it operational compliance. Call it risk management. Call it whatever survives a change of CEO, a change of government, and a tribunal hearing. The substance is the same. The packaging determines whether it lasts.

What Employers Should Take from This

Whether or not your organisation holds or pursues B Corp certification, the JEDI framework contains a useful test. Look at the 19 actions. Identify the 11 that are structural. Ask whether your organisation is doing them – not because a certification body requires it, but because a tribunal would expect to see evidence of them.

Policy audits with documented stakeholder input. Structured hiring with bias reduction mechanisms. Disaggregated workforce data analysed by protected characteristic. Third-party verification. Accessibility compliance against a testable standard. Procurement audits. These are not “JEDI actions.” They are the operational foundations of a defensible position under the Equality Act.

From October 2026, the preventative duty standard moves from “reasonable steps” to “all reasonable steps.” The two-part question a tribunal will likely ask is: what did you do, and was there anything else you could reasonably have done? If the answer to the second question is yes, you fail the test.

The irony of B Lab’s overhaul is that they got the substance largely right. Eleven of their 19 actions would survive scrutiny in a tribunal. But by wrapping those actions in language that sounds like a campaign rather than a compliance framework, they may have made it harder for exactly the organisations that need them most to adopt them.

Build the process. Document the steps. Let the substance speak for itself.

–

Heeral Gudka is the founder of Convergent Consulting and author of The Unity Playbook and Freedom of Expression and Belief Conflicts are the New EDI Frontier. Convergent works with employers on structural EDI built on solid ground, not emotion or optics, harassment risk assessment, and the “all reasonable steps” standard under the Employment Rights Act 2025.

Sources
  • B Lab Global, “Impact Topic: Justice, Equity, Diversity, Inclusion” (May 2025)
  • B Lab U.S. & Canada, “The JEDI Standards, Simplified” (November 2025)
  • B Lab Standards v2.1, Impact Topic Summary for JEDI (August 2025)
  • Allay (UK) Ltd v Gehlen [2021] EAT